Haleigh Cummings: Missing Since February 10th, 2009

On February 10, 2009, a 5-year-old child named Haleigh Cummings was reported missing from her home in Satsuma, a small unincorporated community in Putnam County, Florida. The phone call to 911 came in the early morning hours, immediately launching a community and law enforcement search effort that would gain national attention.

Danielle Imbo and Richard Petrone Jr.: Missing Since February 5th, 2005

Philadelphia, February 19, 2005. Snow fell gently on the historic streets, softening the city’s chaos under a delicate white blanket. South Street resisted the hush of winter, alive with music spilling from dimly lit bars, bursts of laughter, and the hum of late-night traffic. Inside Abilene’s, Danielle Imbo and Richard Petrone Jr. appeared to be just another couple enjoying a night out. They were seen laughing, leaning close to one another, their rekindled connection in progress. As the clock approached midnight, they stepped outside into the biting cold, leaving behind friends and any trace of themselves. Their footsteps vanished along with them, lost in the fresh snow that covered Philadelphia by morning.

Jason Jolkowski: Missing Since June 13th, 2001

Before you jump to any conclusions, let’s look at Jason as a person. By all accounts, he was a reserved, soft-spoken individual who struggled a bit with a mild learning disability that primarily affected his speech and language. But let me tell you, that never held him back. He graduated from high school, enrolled in college, held down steady work, and even nurtured ambitions of entering a radio broadcasting program. This was not someone living on the fringes; Jason had a stable home life, no known enemies, and a brand-new career prospect on the horizon. He was about to start a job at SITEL (through a relative) and had even considered seminary school. This young man was going places—until that fateful day in June.

Brian Shaffer: Missing Since April 1st, 2006

It was a quiet, unremarkable night in Columbus, Ohio, in the spring of 2006—until it wasn't. Under the dim glow of streetlights, Brian Shaffer, a promising 27-year-old medical student, vanished. To say he disappeared would be an understatement. He slipped through the cracks of reality itself, leaving behind a mystery so confounding, so chilling, that it continues to haunt everyone who dares to look into it.

Joshua Guimond: Missing Since November 9th, 2002

20-year-old Joshua Guimond, a promising student at St. John's University in Minnesota, was last seen leaving a party at a friend's apartment on the night of Saturday, November 9, 2002. The walk back to his dorm shouldn't have taken more than three minutes, but Josh never made it home.

Kevin Jay Ayotte: Missing Since September 30th, 1982

On a crisp autumn afternoon in 1982, the serene woods of Sugarbush, Minnesota became the backdrop for one of the state’s most enduring mysteries. Kevin Ayotte, a 3-year-old boy, disappeared from his family’s summer home without a trace. His mother, who had only briefly stepped outside, returned to find that Kevin and the family’s Springer Spaniel puppy, Flash, were both gone. The time was approximately 4:45 pm. Kevin’s older brother was still inside the home, but Kevin and Flash had vanished.

Johnny Gosch: Missing Since September 5th, 1982

On the morning of September 5, 1982, 12-year-old Johnny Gosch, a paperboy from West Des Moines, Iowa, disappeared without a trace. To this day, his case remains unsolved, and no clues have been found to indicate what happened to him. Let's take a look at the circumstances surrounding Johnny’s disappearance and explore why it remains one of America’s most mysterious unsolved cases.

Amy Sue Pagnac: Missing Since August 5, 1989

On a seemingly ordinary summer afternoon over 30 years ago, a Minnesota teenager vanished without a trace, leaving behind a trail of unanswered questions and a family desperate for answers. This is the chilling story of Amy Sue Pagnac, whose disappearance continues to baffle investigators and haunt her loved ones.

August 5, 1989: Thirteen-year-old Amy and her stepfather, Marshall Midden, were returning to their home in Maple Grove after a visit to the family farm. At approximately 4:30 P.M., they stopped at a Holiday Inn gasoline station in Osseo, MN, just two miles from their home. Marshall went inside to use the restroom, but when he returned, Amy was gone. It was as if she had vanished into thin air.

Daniel Lee Newville: Missing Since July 31st, 2002

On July 31, 2002, 18-year-old Daniel Lee Newville was released from prison after serving a sentence for a probation violation. To celebrate his freedom, the young man attended a party in a house in New London, Minnesota where he stayed until the early morning hours of August 1. After failing to get a ride home, Daniel decided to walk back to his friend's residence a mile or two away — but never arrived. Two decades later, speculation continues about what really happened at the party that night and if the other attendees know more about Daniel's disappearance than they are willing to admit.

Alexis Patterson: Missing Since May 3, 2002

On the brisk morning of May 3, 2002, Alexis “Lexi” Patterson, age seven, prepared for another day of first grade at Hi-Mount Boulevard School in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Despite her bouncy personality, her morning had begun sourly: the night before, she’d quarreled with her mother, Ayanna Patterson, over undone homework. Her punishment was the loss of a prized privilege—bringing cupcakes to class. Dressed in a purple blouse (or maybe a striped shirt) and a bright red hooded jacket with gray stripes, she left home with a pink Barbie backpack in tow.

Vicki Sundgaard: Missing Since April 19th, 1987

Sundgaard was last seen at a party on Cedar Street in Alexandria, Minnesota during the early morning hours of April 19, 1987, Easter Sunday. She has never been heard from again. Her vehicle was found parked a few blocks away the following morning. Sundgaard's purse and asthma inhaler were inside it. Her loved ones stated her asthma had been bothering her in the days leading up to her disappearance and they did not believe she would have left her inhaler behind. She also left behind her two young sons, which is uncharacteristic of her. A week before her disappearance, Sundgaard told her sister she planned to leave her husband and move out of the area. The couple had two young sons and Sungaard stated he was violent, and she did not trust him around the children. 

Jermaine Hunter: Missing Since April 6th, 2012

30-year-old Jermaine Hunter wasn't the type of person who would go a long time without talking with his family — rather he would talk with his siblings every day. So when Jermaine suddenly went radio silent in April 2012, his sister Shekitha Hunter immediately knew something was terribly wrong: “You know, my brother was the type of person who called you every day. If he called you at 2, he would call you back at 5 to make sure you were OK. He was the type of brother who called you to let you know he was all right. So I just can’t understand how he just disappeared off the face of the Earth."

Sara Bushland: Missing Since April 3rd, 1996

On the crisp afternoon of April 3, 1996, Sara Bushland, a 15-year-old sophomore at Spooner High School, stepped off her school bus and into the rural quiet of her family’s driveway in Spring Lake, Wisconsin. It was a moment that should have been ordinary—just another end to a school day, another trek home—but it would mark the beginning of a chilling mystery that has haunted her family and community for nearly three decades. Sara’s life had been turbulent leading up to that fateful day. She had recently moved from Colorado to Wisconsin, seeking refuge from the strict rules of her father’s house, only to find herself ensnared in new tensions and conflicts. Living with her mother, stepfather, and stepbrothers in their converted garage home on a sprawling 65-acre property, Sara was grappling with the typical angst of adolescence, compounded by a mix of new and older friends, some of whom were much older.

LeeAnna "Beaner" Warner: Missing Since June 14, 2003

LeeAnna was last seen walking home from a friend's house, which was a block and a half from her own residence. She had gone to play with the friend at 4:30 p.m., but no one was home at her friend's residence. She was last seen walking on southwest Second or Third Street, westbound, between 5:00 and 5:15 p.m.

LeeAnna's mother, Tiffany Kaelin Whittaker, more commonly known as Kaelin Warner, began looking for her at 5:30 p.m., enlisting neighborhood children to help. When the search turned up no sign of LeeAnna's whereabouts, Kaelin called the police between 8:40 and 9:00 p.m.

Morgan Chauntel Nick: Missing Since June 9, 1995

Nick attended a Little League Baseball game with her mother in Alma, Arkansas on June 9, 1995. She joined her friends to catch lightning bugs near the baseball field later in the evening. Nick was last seen at approximately 10:45 p.m. as she stood near her mother's Nissan Stanza in the parking lot. She was emptying sand from her shoes at the time. Nick has never been heard from again. Witnesses told authorities that they observed an unidentified Caucasian male watching Nick play on the field earlier in the night. The man apparently approached a group of children playing with Nick and asked them a question; investigators have not publicly released any additional details about the conversation.

Susan Anne Swedell: Missing Since January 19, 1988

Swedell was employed at the K-Mart retail store in Oak Park Heights, Minnesota in 1988. She phoned her family members from work at 4:00 p.m. on January 19, 1988. Swedell said that she planned to go straight home after her shift ended to watch a movie. She changed into a short skirt before she departed from work, which was considered odd due to the snowy conditions at the time.

Anthony G. Urciuoli Jr: Missing Since January 24, 2001

Urciuoli was employed as a server at the Dutchess Diner in Poughkeepsie, New York in 2001. He was last seen by his parents at his family's residence near the Galleria Mall on January 24, 2001. Urciuoli received a page from an unknown person and told his parents he was going to play pool with a friend at approximately 11:30 p.m. He has never been heard from again. Authorities were unable to trace the page Urciuoli received the night he vanished.

Hang Lee: Missing Since January 15, 1993

Hang was last seen leaving her family's residence in St. Paul, Minnesota on January 12, 1993. She left home with a female friend, Kia "Nikki" Lee, who is not related to Hang. Kia returned home shortly alone afterwards. Hang's parents, who are refugees from Laos and did not speak English at the time, reported her as a missing person to authorities. She left behind all her clothing, her college savings, a $100 paycheck and her purse, which contained a knife and a lead ball for personal protection. Just prior to leaving her home, she told her brother that if she did come back, he should search for her because she did not trust Kia.

Lauren Gail Andersen: Missing Since November 15, 1981

Andersen was last seen in St. Louis Park, Minnesota on November 15, 1981. An unknown individual picked her up at her parents' residence at 6:15 p.m. She has never been heard from again. Andersen was a regular patron of the Cardinal Bar in Minneapolis, Minnesota at the time of her disappearance. She left behind personal belongings including her medication, vehicle, clothing and toothbrush, and she has not used her checking account since her disappearance.

Veronica Safranski: Missing Since October 27, 1996

Veronica Safranski was last seen leaving a Halloween party in Warren, Marshall County, MN on October 26th, 1996. The victim was wearing an American Indian costume at the time of her disappearance. She has not been seen or heard from since.

Safranski attended a Halloween costume party with a friend at Mick's Bar and Grill in Warren, Minnesota on October 26, 1996. A photo of the restaurant is posted below this case summary. Safranski's friend was unable to locate her inside the establishment at approximately 12:30 a.m. Witnesses told authorities that Safranski and Kevin Skjerven were seen together around the same time. They departed from the restaurant in his black 1997 Dodge Power Wagon pickup truck with Oregon license plates. Safranski has never been heard from again.